Options vs. Prediction Markets: Why Your Options Chain Was the Original Prediction Market
Kalshi and Polymarket price whether something happens. Options price how far. Here is how to read both, with worked examples, and what the evidence says about who actually gets paid.
Prediction markets have gone from a curiosity to big business. According to a Pew Research Center analysis of data from The Block, Kalshi and Polymarket together traded about $2.0 billion in July 2025. In July 2026, they traded about $53 billion. Roughly 80 percent of June and July's volume was sports.
I've spent 24 years trading options, and readers now ask me whether they should be doing this instead. My answer: if you trade options, you've been using a prediction market all along. You just haven't been reading it that way.
Below, I'll show you how to pull the market's odds out of any options chain, how to tell a high win rate from an actual edge, and a one-minute habit you can run on your next trade.
The short answer: A prediction market contract pays $1 if something happens, so its price is the market's odds. An options chain prices those same odds at every strike at once, and it also prices how far the stock might move. In both markets, the evidence shows that long shots are systematically overpriced, which tells you which side you want to be on.

Combined Kalshi and Polymarket monthly trading volume, January 2025 through July 2026 Combined Kalshi and Polymarket monthly volume, January 2025 through July 2026. July 2026 ran about 26 times July 2025. Source: Pew Research Center analysis of data from The Block.
How a $1 Contract Actually Works
Start with the simplest version. Say there's a contract asking whether the Fed will cut rates at its next meeting, and "yes" trades at 30 cents.
Buy 100 contracts and you pay $30. If the Fed cuts, each contract pays $1, so you collect $100 and keep a $70 profit. If it doesn't, you lose your $30. That 30 cent price is the market saying roughly a 30 percent chance.
There's one more line on the ticket. Kalshi charges a trading fee of 7 cents times the price times one minus the price, per contract, rounded up to the next cent. On this order that's $1.47, so your real cost is $31.47.
Build the Same Bet With Two Options
You can build that exact contract from two options. Take a hypothetical index ETF at $600 with options 30 days out. These prices are modeled, not live quotes, using about 18 percent implied volatility with normal skew. Buy the $620 call and sell the $621 call. That one dollar wide call spread costs about $0.28, or $28.
Above $621 at expiration, it pays $100. Below $620, nothing. Same payout as the Fed contract. And just like the Fed contract, the price is the odds: $0.28 on a $1 payout reads as about a 28 percent chance the ETF finishes above $620.

A one dollar wide call spread compared with a binary event contract payoff A one dollar wide call spread is a yes or no contract in everything but name. Its $0.28 price reads as about a 28 percent chance of finishing above $620.
On a real chain, a spread that narrow trades poorly. A wider one gives the same read: the 620/625 call spread costs about $1.31, and $1.31 divided by the $5 width is 26 cents on the dollar.
Read Your Chain Like a Prediction Market
Do that at every strike and the chain becomes a forecast. Same $600 ETF, 30 days out:
Strike | Market's odds of finishing above | Call delta |
|---|---|---|
$570 | about 84 percent | 0.83 |
$585 | about 72 percent | 0.70 |
$600 | about 55 percent | 0.53 |
$615 | about 35 percent | 0.33 |
$630 | about 17 percent | 0.16 |
The odds come from pricing a one dollar spread at each strike. The delta is printed on every chain your broker shows you. They track closely, which is why delta is the shortcut I use. A 0.16 delta call is the market calling a finish above that strike roughly a one in six shot.

An options chain read as an implied probability curve across strikes An options chain is a prediction market with a contract at every strike. Read it this way and you see the market's whole forecast, not one question.
One caution. These odds lean a little pessimistic, because people pay extra for protection, the same way homeowners pay more for insurance than the average claim costs. That extra is exactly where option sellers earn their keep, and we'll come back to it.
Whether vs. How Far: An Earnings Example
Picture a hypothetical $100 stock reporting earnings this week. A prediction market asks, "Will the company beat estimates?" and "yes" trades at 75 cents. The options market asks something else. With implied volatility around 60 percent, the at-the-money straddle costs about $6.60, which tells you the market expects a move of roughly 6.6 percent in either direction.
Now the report comes out. The company beats, and the stock falls 8 percent on soft guidance.
The "yes" holder gets paid. If you sold puts or own the shares, the beat didn't help you at all. What mattered was the size of the move, and the straddle had already warned you it could be about that big. That's why the expected move is the number I check before any event, not the odds of a beat. It also tells you where the danger zone is. A put strike 5 percent below the stock sat inside the expected move and got run over by the 8 percent drop. A strike 10 percent below sat outside it and survived.
A binary contract can't price how far. An options chain prices little else.
Both Markets Overcharge for Long Shots
Three economists at University College Dublin studied more than 300,000 Kalshi prices from 2021 through April 2025. In Makers and Takers: The Economics of the Kalshi Prediction Market, they found that cheap contracts won less often than their prices implied, and expensive ones won slightly more often.
The results:
Takers, who trade against posted quotes, lost about 31 percent on average after fees.
Makers, who post the quotes, lost about 10 percent.
Contracts priced at 10 cents or less lost buyers more than 60 percent of their money on average.

Kalshi returns by contract price showing the favorite-longshot bias In more than 300,000 Kalshi prices, the cheapest contracts did the most damage, and the people taking prices lost three times as much as the people setting them.
Here's how a small mispricing turns into a big loss on a real ticket. Buy 100 long shot contracts at 5 cents. That's $5, plus a 34 cent fee. If the true chance of winning is 3 percent, not the 5 percent the price implies, you'll collect about $3 on average for every $5.34 you spend. That's a loss of roughly 44 percent, and it comes from being wrong by just two percentage points.
The fee makes it worse. On that order it's about 6.8 percent of what you paid, versus about 0.36 percent on 95 cent contracts. Buy a single 5 cent contract and the rounding turns a third of a cent into a full penny, a 20 percent fee.

Kalshi fee as a percent of contract price across prices Kalshi's fee, as a share of what you pay, is nearly 20 times higher on a 5 cent contract than on a 95 cent one. Long shot buyers pay twice: once in the price, once in the fee.
Options show the same pattern. Think of an option seller as an insurance company. Over long stretches, index options have tended to price in bigger moves than actually show up, the same way insurers collect more in premiums than they pay out in claims. Traders call that gap the variance risk premium. It's largest in out-of-the-money puts, the long shots of the options world.
It's the same instinct in both places: people overpay for a small chance at a big payoff and for insurance against disaster. The disciplined seller of that insurance has historically been paid. That's the foundation of how I trade premium.
Every Credit Spread Has a Price in Cents
So if selling long shots is the side that gets paid, should you sell the cheapest ones you can find? No, and this is where most new premium sellers go wrong. Being on the right side isn't enough. You also have to be paid enough to survive the day the long shot comes in.
Every credit spread is a yes or no contract. Divide the credit by the width of the spread and you get the price, in cents, of the contract you're selling. Subtract it from 100 and you have roughly the win rate you need to break even. Because a spread has a zone between the strikes where the loss is only partial, the math isn't exact, but it's close enough to trade with.
Same $600 ETF, 30 days out, modeled prices:
Put credit spread | Credit | Price in cents | Break-even win rate | One max loss erases |
|---|---|---|---|---|
580/575 | $1.04 | 21 cents | 79 percent | about 4 wins |
560/555 | $0.44 | 9 cents | 91 percent | about 10 wins |
540/535 | $0.16 | 3 cents | 97 percent | about 30 wins |
The 540/535 wins most often, so it feels safest. It's actually the most fragile spread on the table.
Here's why. Nobody knows the true odds of a crash to within a point or two, least of all for rare events. So ask a simple question: what happens if the market's odds are off by just 1 percentage point?
On the 540/535, that small miss costs about 5 cents per spread, roughly a third of the 16 cents you collected. On the 580/575, the same 5 cents is about 5 percent of a $1.04 credit. Same mistake, six times the damage. The far-out spread has almost no cushion for being wrong, and the odds of rare events are exactly the ones that are hardest to get right.
The further out you sell, the less room you have to be wrong. Given the choice, I would rather be paid enough to survive my own errors. Even then, the edge only shows up over a large number of trades, which is why boredom is the premium seller's greatest asset. For the mechanics of choosing strikes and widths, see credit spreads explained.
How I Actually Use Prediction Markets
I don't trade them. I read them, two ways.
1. A pre-event odds check. Before a Fed meeting, I look at what the crowd expects. If a rate hold is priced at 95 percent, the decision itself probably won't move stocks much. The risk is the 5 percent surprise and the statement that follows, and the options chain's expected move tells me how big a reaction is priced.
2. A gut check on my own forecasts. If I'm sure of something the crowd prices at 60 cents, I'm probably overconfident, and I'd rather learn that before it shows up in my position size.
As a place to trade, I'm skeptical. They price whether instead of how far, the crowd overpays for long shots, and when roughly 80 percent of the volume is wagers on games, the line between investing and gambling is thin. The rules are unsettled too: federal appeals courts have split on whether states can regulate sports event contracts.
A Three-Step Habit for Your Own Chain
You don't need a prediction market to use any of this. Here's the routine I run on every trade, and it takes about a minute:
Read the odds. Look at the delta of the strike you're considering. A 0.20 delta is the market calling it roughly a one in five chance of finishing in the money.
Price it in cents. For any credit spread, divide the credit by the width. A $1.00 credit on a $5 spread is a 20 cent contract, so you need to win about 80 percent of the time to break even.
Check the event risk. If earnings or a Fed meeting falls before expiration, look at the expected move and ask whether your short strike sits inside it.
If the odds are thinner than I want, the price doesn't pay me enough to be wrong, or the short strike sits inside an event's expected move, I pass.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the difference between options and prediction markets?
A prediction market is a yes or no bet. The contract pays $1 if the event happens, so the price tells you the odds and nothing else. Options go a step further. They pay based on how far a stock moves past the strike, which means a full chain of them tells you the odds and the size of the move the market expects.
The Bottom Line
Prediction markets are bigger now. They aren’t new. Options traders have been pricing the odds of events for decades, at every strike, with payoffs they can shape and risk they can define.
The lesson from both markets is the same. The crowd overpays for long shots, and a high win rate isn't an edge. Sell what's overpriced, get paid enough to survive being wrong, keep each loss small, as I lay out in how much to risk on any one options trade, and give the edge enough trades to show up.
Prediction markets ask whether. Options ask how far. In my portfolios, how far is the only question that pays the bills.
Probabilities over predictions,
Andy Crowder
📩 Start trading smarter and more confidently, join thousands of readers who get The Option Premium every week.
📺 Want more education and community?
🎥 Subscribe on YouTube for in-depth tutorials and live trade breakdowns.
📘 Join the conversation on Facebook for exclusive insights, discussions, and real-time updates.
Disclaimer: This is educational content only. Not investment advice. Options involve risk and aren't suitable for all investors. Examples are illustrative. Real results will vary. Talk to professionals before you risk real money
