Why Your Trading Strategy Keeps Failing (It's Not What You Think)

Let me tell you about the moment I finally understood why I kept blowing up accounts.

It wasn't my indicators. It wasn't my timing. It wasn't even the market itself. It was something far more fundamental, and far more fixable. I was trading strategies I didn't actually believe in.

And if you've ever found yourself abandoning a perfectly good system after a few losses, closing winning trades too early, or flip-flopping between strategies like you're channel surfing? You're probably making the same mistake.

Here's the uncomfortable truth: The biggest threat to your trading account isn't market volatility. It's unexamined beliefs.

The Hidden Foundation of Every Trade You Place

Think about the last options trade you placed. Maybe you sold a put. Maybe you bought a call spread. Whatever it was, you had reasons, right?

But here's what most traders miss: Those "reasons" are actually assumptions wrapped up as logic.

When you sell that SPY put at 40 IV rank, you're making three massive assumptions:

First, you're assuming implied volatility is inflated compared to what will actually happen. Second, you're betting SPY won't breach your strike before expiration. Third, you're counting on theta decay to erode that premium faster than delta moves against you.

Those aren't just technical observations. They're beliefs about how markets behave.

And here's where it gets really interesting: If you haven't consciously examined these beliefs, if you can't articulate why you trust them, then you're essentially trading blind.

Dr. Van K. Tharp, arguably the greatest trading psychologist of our time, spent decades hammering home one revolutionary insight:

"You don't trade the markets. You trade your beliefs about the markets."

This changes everything once you really get it.

The Belief Gap That's Killing Your Consistency

Let's run a quick diagnostic.

Have you ever:

• Exited a trade early because it made you uncomfortable, even though your system said hold?

• Skipped a valid setup because you were "gun shy" after a recent loss?

• Doubled down on a losing position to "make back" what you lost?

• Switched strategies mid-drawdown because you lost faith in your approach?

If you answered yes to any of these (and be honest, we all have), you've experienced what I call The Belief Gap.

The Belief Gap is the distance between what your strategy tells you to do and what you actually trust enough to execute.

And it's absolutely devastating to long-term performance.

Here's why: Options trading demands consistency. Your edge, whether it's selling volatility, capturing spreads, or trading directional, only materializes over dozens of trades. Not one. Not five. Dozens.

But if you can't stick with your approach because your beliefs are unstable? That edge never has time to work.

You're constantly starting over. Constantly second-guessing. Constantly reacting instead of executing.

Where Traders Get Their Beliefs (And Why It Doesn't Work)

Most traders build their strategies like this:

They find a successful trader online. They take a course. They backtest a system from a forum. They see results and think: "I'll trade this."

But there's a fatal flaw in this approach.

You've adopted the mechanics without building the conviction.

It's like learning a language by memorizing phrases without understanding grammar. It works fine until you hit an unexpected situation, then you freeze.

In trading, that "unexpected situation" is volatility spikes, gap moves, earnings surprises, or any of the hundred things that make real markets messier than backtests.

When those moments hit, borrowed conviction evaporates. Fast.

Van Tharp understood this deeply. He studied thousands of traders and found the same pattern again and again: The most successful traders weren't running the "best" systems. They were running systems that matched their personality, risk tolerance, and fundamental beliefs about market behavior.

Think about what that means for options specifically:

• If you believe in mean reversion but you're trading momentum breakouts, you'll sabotage yourself

• If you can't stomach seeing short strikes tested, high-probability iron condors will torture you

• If you believe markets are random but you're trading patterns, you'll lack conviction when it matters

Your strategy and your beliefs have to be in sync. Otherwise, you're fighting yourself every single day.

The Three-Step Framework for Building Bulletproof Conviction

Alright, enough theory. Let's get practical.

If you want to trade with real conviction, the kind that survives drawdowns and keeps you executing when others are panicking, here's your roadmap:

Step 1: Document Your Trading Philosophy

This is where most traders skip ahead. Don't.

Open a document right now and answer these questions in complete sentences:

What do I believe gives me an edge in the market? (Be specific. "Selling premium in high IV" isn't enough. Why does that create an edge? What market inefficiency are you exploiting?)

What do I believe about risk and loss? (Is losing part of the game, or something to avoid at all costs? Your answer here predicts how you'll behave in drawdowns.)

What do I believe about market predictability? (Are markets trend-driven? Mean-reverting? Mostly random with occasional exploitable patterns? Your belief shapes your entire approach.)

How much uncertainty can I actually handle? (Not what you want to handle. What you've proven you can handle when money's on the line.)

This isn't philosophical navel-gazing. This is operational clarity.

Because once you know what you truly believe, you can build or adapt strategies that work with those beliefs instead of against them.

Step 2: Run the Alignment Test

Now that you've documented your beliefs, it's time for some brutal honesty.

Pull up your last 20 trades. Look at how you actually behaved:

• Did you follow your rules, or did you deviate under pressure?

• Did you size positions based on your stated risk tolerance, or did you wing it?

• Did you close trades according to your system, or did you get emotional?

Here's the hard truth: Your actual trading behavior reveals your real beliefs.

If you say you believe in letting trades run to target, but you consistently close at 30% profit because you're nervous? You don't actually believe in letting trades run. You believe in taking quick profits.

Neither is wrong. But the mismatch between what you say and what you do? That's the problem.

Your job now is to bring them into alignment. Either adjust your beliefs to match your behavior, or adjust your behavior to match your beliefs.

But you can't keep living in the gap.

Step 3: Create Your Trade Filter

Once you've got alignment, you need a pre-trade filter based on your beliefs.

Before you place any trade, run it through these three questions:

1. Does this trade express my edge? Not someone else's edge. Not a setup you saw on Twitter. Your specific edge, based on your specific beliefs about how markets work.

2. Can I handle the worst-case scenario? Not the expected scenario. The worst case. If this trade goes completely against you, will you regret the decision, or just the outcome? If you'll regret the decision, don't take the trade.

3. Will I be able to execute my exit plan regardless of emotions? If the trade moves against you, will you stick to your stop? If it moves for you, will you stick to your target? If the answer is "maybe," you're not ready to take the trade.

This filter does something magical: It eliminates impulsive trades while preserving the ones that truly fit your framework.

You'll take fewer trades. But the ones you take? You'll execute with conviction.

How This Transforms Your Options Trading

Let me paint you a picture of what changes when you get this right:

You stop strategy-hopping. Because you're not trading borrowed systems anymore. You're trading strategies built on beliefs you actually hold.

You stop panicking during drawdowns. Because you knew losses were part of the process. You believed it going in, so you don't abandon ship when it happens.

You stop overthinking every decision. Because you have a framework. You know what fits and what doesn't. The decision becomes obvious.

You start compounding edge. Because you're finally consistent enough for probabilities to do their thing over time.

This is the difference between traders who make it and traders who burn out.

It's not IQ. It's not access to tools. It's not even work ethic.

It's alignment between belief and execution.

The Missing Piece: Sizing Your Conviction

Now here's where this gets really interesting.

Once you've got clarity on your beliefs and alignment in your execution, there's one more leverage point that separates good traders from great ones:

Position sizing.

Van Tharp called it "the most important concept in trading." And he was right.

Because here's the thing: Most traders obsess over win rate. They want to be right 70%, 80%, 90% of the time.

But win rate barely matters compared to how you size your positions.

You can be right 70% of the time and still blow up if your losses are too big. Or you can be right 40% of the time and crush it if you size intelligently.

Position sizing isn't just about risk management. It's about amplifying your edge when you have conviction and protecting yourself when you don't.

That's the topic we'll dive deep into next week, because once you understand how to size based on conviction, not fear, your results will change dramatically.

Your Action Plan for This Week

Here's what you need to do:

📝 Complete the philosophy exercise. Don't skip this. Write out your answers to those four core questions. This is the foundation everything else builds on.

🔍 Run your alignment audit. Review your last 20 trades. Where did your behavior diverge from your stated beliefs? Be honest. Write it down.

✅ Build your trade filter. Create a checklist based on the three questions above. Don't place another trade without running it through this filter.

🧠 Commit to one system. Stop exploring new strategies for the next 30 days. Focus on executing what you believe with consistency. Let your edge develop.

Trading isn't about finding the perfect strategy. It's about finding your strategy—the one that aligns with who you are, what you believe, and how you naturally handle risk and uncertainty.

Get that alignment right, and the market becomes a lot less chaotic.

Not because the market changed.

Because you did.

Probabilities over predictions,

Andy Crowder

🎯 Ready to Elevate Your Options Trading?
Subscribe to The Option Premium, a free weekly newsletter delivering:
✅ Actionable strategies.
✅ Step-by-step trade breakdowns.
✅ Market insights for all conditions (bullish, bearish, or neutral).

📩 Get smarter, more confident trading insights delivered to your inbox every week.

📺 Follow Me on YouTube:
🎥 Explore in-depth tutorials, trade setups, and exclusive content to sharpen your skills.