The Statistical Truth About Options Trading: What Most "Gurus" Won’t Tell You

When I look at the world of options trading today, I see a troubling pattern that’s been around for way too long. Promises of overnight riches—300%, 400%, or even 1,200% returns in a matter of days—dominate the conversation. These claims rarely come with any discussion of the risks involved. They glorify risky, low-probability strategies like buying far out-of-the-money puts or calls while ignoring the more sustainable approach of selling premium using a variety of high-probability options trading strategies.

Let me be clear: I’m not here to say that selling premium is the only path to success. Some professional traders make a living predominantly buying options. But they are the exception, not the rule because at best, buying options has a 50% probability of success. A coin flip. And if you are a believer in statistical truths, like the law of large numbers, you understand that’s not a winning philosophy. Building a strategy around seeking consistent, sky-high returns through buying options isn’t just unrealistic—it’s statistically unsound. Extraordinary results can happen, but they are outliers, not a foundation for long-term success.

The Noise vs. What Matters

What frustrates me most isn’t the hype; it’s what the hype distracts us from. Investors often overlook what truly matters: realistic trading strategies, transparency, and disciplined risk management. Trading is not, and never will be, a get-rich-quick scheme. It’s a journey—one that requires patience, education, and a commitment to mastering statistical options trading strategies.

To succeed, self-directed investors need to focus on the fundamentals:

• Position sizing that aligns with their risk tolerance.

• Risk management principles that protect their capital.

• A disciplined, long-term approach rooted in high-probability trades.

Instead, many flock to services that promise easy money while delivering disappointment. Worst of all, they are often repeat offenders continuing to fall prey to what marketers take advantage of, the “get-rich-quick-scheme”. Why? Are we so eager for quick fixes that we ignore the statistical truth? Options trading success is rooted in probabilities, not predictions, and the sooner traders embrace this, the better.

What we need to understand is that marketers, particularly in the financial publishing industry, recognize the psychological appeal of get-rich-quick schemes and exploit it as a powerful marketing ploy. These schemes tap into fundamental human desires: the dream of financial freedom, fear of missing out (FOMO), and the impatience to achieve wealth quickly.

No, it’s not statistically sound.
Here’s why:

1. Low-Probability Outcomes:

   • Most get-rich-quick strategies rely on low-probability, high-reward trades, such as buying far out-of-the-money options. These strategies have a small chance of success and often result in significant losses for most traders.

2. Survivorship Bias:

   • Marketers often highlight rare success stories while ignoring the majority of failures. This skews perceptions and creates an illusion of high success rates, even though the data doesn’t support it.

3. Misleading Risk-Reward Trade-offs:

   • Many schemes overemphasize potential rewards without properly explaining the associated risks or the likelihood of losing the entire investment.

4. The Law of Large Numbers:

   • Over time, statistical realities take over. Strategies built on improbable outcomes tend to fail because they lack the consistent edge needed for long-term success.

5. Regret Aversion:

   • Marketers prey on the idea that missing out on a "life-changing trade" will lead to regret, but statistically, these trades are more likely to lead to losses than gains.

The Power of Probabilities in Options Trading

Here’s a key fact most investors don’t realize: stocks and ETFs have only a 50/50 chance of moving up or down.  It’s a coin flip. But options trading allows you to tilt the odds in your favor. Tools like Probability of Expiring Out-of-the-Money (OTM) or delta give traders the ability to structure trades with success rates far above 50%. These aren’t “secrets”—they’re data points available to anyone with the right tools and mindset.

Let’s take a closer look at one of these tools:

• Probability of Expiring OTM: This metric tells you the likelihood that an option will expire worthless, allowing you to design trades with higher probabilities of success.

• Delta: Think of delta as a proxy for probability. For example, a delta of 0.15 roughly translates to an 85% chance that the option will expire out-of-the-money.

A Practical Example: Bear Call Spread on SPY

To illustrate, let’s say I believe the SPDR S&P 500 ETF (SPY) is overbought and due for a pullback. My goal is to place a trade with an 85% probability of success, using a bear call spread—a defined-risk, bearish options strategy.

Here’s how I would structure it:

• Sell the 638 call and buy the 642 call, creating a bear call spread.

• The 638 call has an 86.35% probability of expiring OTM. Moreover, there’s only a 10.56% chance that SPY will close above 642 at expiration.

• The premium collected for the spread is $0.50, offering a potential return of 14.3% if SPY remains below 638 at expiration. However, if SPY moved lower we would look to manage the winner by locking in early profits.

This trade balances risk and reward, leveraging probabilities to create a sustainable edge. Instead of chasing larger returns with lower probabilities, I focus on consistency (choosing deltas between 0.15 and 0.30)—because, over the long haul, the math works in my favor.

Balancing Risk and Reward

Every options trader must grapple with this question: Is it worth taking on more risk for high-probability returns? For instance, choosing a trade with an 80% probability of success might yield more premium, but at what cost? You’re giving up statistical certainty for marginal gains.

In my view, the answer lies in understanding the law of large numbers, but more importantly your goals and risk tolerance. Honestly, it depends on how realistic your expectations are when it comes to returns. If you value consistency, as I do, and believe in statistical laws, then focusing on high-probability options trading strategies makes sense. High-probability options selling strategies emphasize consistency over large, one-off wins. By risking smaller amounts relative to potential returns, traders mitigate the risk of catastrophic losses while allowing the statistical edge to compound over time. It’s not flashy, but it works—and it minimizes the stress of low-probability trades.

How Technology Has Leveled the Playing Field

Two decades ago, trading options felt like entering a secret society. Tools like real-time options chains, delta analysis, and probability calculators were the domain of institutional investors. Retail traders were left in the dark, forced to rely on brokers who often dismissed options as “too complex.”

But the landscape has changed. Advances in trading technology and platforms have given self-directed investors access to professional-grade tools. Today, anyone with an internet connection can analyze high-probability credit spreads, leverage delta for probability assessments, and execute trades with precision.

So why aren’t more retail traders using these tools the way professionals do? The knowledge is there. The technology is there. All that’s missing is the discipline to apply them consistently.

Why Now Is a Special Time for Options Trading

We’re at an inflection point in the world of options trading. The accessibility of tools like Probability of Expiring ITM, Probability of Expiring OTM, Greeks, IV Rank, Expected Move, Option Flow among numerous other helpful metrics, paired with educational resources, has opened the door for a new wave of investors to embrace statistically sound strategies. I believe the next decade will see a surge in probability-based options trading, with early adopters leading the charge.

Key Takeaways

1. Ignore the hype: Focus on strategies that align with probabilities, not promises of unrealistic returns.

2. Embrace technology: Leverage tools like delta and Probability of Expiring OTM, IV Rank, Expected Move, Option Flow, etc. to gain an edge.

3. Prioritize consistency: High-probability trades may not be glamorous, but they’re the foundation of sustainable success.

4. Educate yourself: As a professional options trader for 22 years, I urge you not to rely on “gurus” with false promises. Instead, I humbly invite you to make The Option Premium your resource of choice, a place where can educate yourself, gain valuable insights, and build confidence in your trading journey.

Options trading IS a journey, not a shortcut to riches. By focusing on the fundamentals—probabilities, risk management, and consistent execution—you can unlock the true potential of options.

Let probabilities guide your trades,

Andy

🎯 Ready to Elevate Your Options Trading?
Subscribe to The Option Premium—a free weekly newsletter delivering:
✅ Actionable strategies.
✅ Step-by-step trade breakdowns.
✅ Market insights for all conditions (bullish, bearish, or neutral).

📩 Get smarter, more confident trading insights delivered to your inbox every week.

📺 Follow Me on YouTube:
🎥 Explore in-depth tutorials, trade setups, and exclusive content to sharpen your skills.