You Don’t Trade the Markets—You Trade Your Beliefs About Them

Every trade you place reflects a belief.

That volatility will contract. That price will stay within a range. That a spread will decay favorably.

But most traders never stop to examine the beliefs behind their strategies—and that’s why they struggle to grow.

In this edition of Mental Capital, we explore one of Van Tharp’s greatest teachings—and show how understanding your trading beliefs can unlock better decision-making, risk management, and long-term edge in options.

Dr. Van K. Tharp was a pioneering trading psychologist and coach best known for teaching that you don't trade the markets—you trade your beliefs about the markets. He emphasized that a trader’s success is less about picking the perfect system and more about aligning strategy with personal beliefs, risk tolerance, and consistent execution. Tharp introduced key concepts like position sizing as the true performance lever, the expectancy formula to evaluate systems, and the importance of mental state management to reduce emotional errors. His work is foundational for serious traders, especially those in options, where probabilities, risk, and discipline intersect daily.

📍 Trading Beliefs Drive Every Decision

Let’s break it down:
When you sell a cash-secured put on SPY at 40 IV rank, you’re not just trading a setup.

You’re expressing a belief.
✅ That implied volatility is overstating realized risk
✅ That SPY is unlikely to drop below your strike
✅ That premium decay will work in your favor over time

But what if you don’t know those are your beliefs? What if you don’t actually trust them?

That’s when you:

• Close early at the first sign of red

• Skip the next trade after a loss

• Switch strategies midstream

• Oversize out of desperation, not confidence

This is why Van Tharp’s lesson is so critical. If your beliefs are unexamined—or worse, unstable—your trading becomes reactive, not intentional.

🧠 Why Most Traders Run on Borrowed Beliefs

Many traders inherit strategies from gurus, backtests, or trading forums.

They execute trades, but they haven’t internalized the why.
So when volatility spikes, when earnings surprise, when a spread moves faster than expected—they panic.

Van Tharp warned against this:

That’s especially true in options trading, where:

• Strategies vary wildly in payoff structure

• Risk is nonlinear and can expand quickly

• Probabilities work over time, not per trade

If you’re trading high-IV iron condors but can’t stomach watching the short strikes get tested, your beliefs and your system are out of sync.

🔍 The Solution: Uncover and Align Your Beliefs

Here’s how to apply Van Tharp’s wisdom:

1. Write Down Your Core Trading Beliefs

Examples:

• I believe selling premium with an edge (IV rank + expected move) is statistically advantageous.

• I believe risk must be defined and managed before the trade is placed.

• I believe market randomness means edge plays out over dozens of trades—not each one.

Make this a ritual. It forces clarity. Because until you know what you believe, you’ll default to reacting.

2. Audit Your Strategy for Belief Alignment

Let’s say your belief is: “I can tolerate a 30% drawdown to achieve long-term outperformance.”

But in practice? You cut trades early at 5%, get emotional, and then strategy-hop.

That’s a belief mismatch. And it means your strategy—no matter how good—will break down when tested.

You must bring your risk tolerance, time frame, and expected payoff in line with your actual behavior.

3. Use Beliefs to Improve Trade Selection

Before every trade, ask:

• Does this reflect my edge?

• Am I comfortable with the risk profile?

• If this loses, will I regret the process—or just the result?

If you can’t answer “yes” to all three, skip it.

This is how pros avoid impulse trades—by knowing what aligns with their framework before they click submit.

🔄 Transition to Van Tharp’s Other Master Concept: Position Sizing

Once your beliefs are clear, the next leap is understanding how position sizing  drives performance—not your win rate.

This is another signature Van Tharp insight:

Next week, we’ll explore why most options traders get this wrong—how to reframe size not just as a risk limiter, but as a performance lever.

💡 What This Means for Options Traders

• Don’t copy systems. Build or adapt systems that reflect your beliefs and personality.

• Stop chasing tweaks. Most strategy failures stem from belief misalignment, not bad math.

• Clarify your mental models. Do you really believe in reversion? Trend? Decay? Know your lens.

• Start with process, not prediction. Good trading isn’t about guessing—it’s about executing a belief-based process consistently.

Next Week: Position Sizing as a Performance System — Van Tharp’s Most Overlooked Lesson for Options Traders

We’ll cover why size—not setup—is the lever behind durable success.
How to build a position sizing framework that adapts to your edge, matches your risk comfort, and compounds over time.

Until then:
🧠 Audit your beliefs.
📋 Align your systems.
💡 Trade what you believe—not what you borrowed.

Probabilities over predictions,

Andy Crowder

🎯 Ready to Elevate Your Options Trading?
Subscribe to The Option Premium—a free weekly newsletter delivering:
✅ Actionable strategies.
✅ Step-by-step trade breakdowns.
✅ Market insights for all conditions (bullish, bearish, or neutral).

📩 Get smarter, more confident trading insights delivered to your inbox every week.

📺 Follow Me on YouTube:
🎥 Explore in-depth tutorials, trade setups, and exclusive content to sharpen your skills.