The Seven Pitfalls That Derail Options Traders

(And the Habits That Prevent Them)

Markets have an uncanny way of exposing human weakness. In options trading, it isn’t usually the strategy that breaks a trader, it’s the behavior behind it.

Options amplify both potential and risk. With leverage, probability, and time decay working in concert, the smallest lapse in discipline can unravel months of progress. The traders who endure aren’t the ones with the most complex models. They’re the ones who sidestep the timeless mistakes that have taken down countless others.

Here are seven of the most destructive habits, and how to avoid them.

1. Greed: The Mirage of Leverage

Options offer extraordinary leverage. That power seduces traders into betting too heavily on long shots or sizing trades far beyond what their account can handle.

📉 Example: A trader buys a weekly out-of-the-money call on a fast-moving stock. The stock rallies, but volatility collapses and the option still loses value. The trader blames the market instead of their misunderstanding of option pricing.

Avoid It:

• Keep position sizes small, no single trade should threaten your capital base.

• Favor spreads or defined-risk structures over naked speculation.

• Take partial profits along the way; consistency beats chasing home runs.

2. Impatience: Ignoring Time Decay

Every option is in a race against the calendar. Many beginners ignore theta decay, buying short-dated contracts where the odds are stacked against them.

Avoid It:

• When possible, sell time instead of buying it.

• Use spreads that work with probability rather than against it.

• Stick to expirations with 30-60 days left, where time decay isn’t as punishing.

3. Fear: Emotional Trading

Fear turns disciplined traders into erratic ones. It convinces you to hang onto losers because “they might come back,” and to exit winners long before they’ve reached their potential.

Avoid It:

• Trust the probabilities built into your trade, not your panic.

• Predetermine exit rules-whether stop-losses or rolling criteria.

• Let profitable trades reach a meaningful percentage of max profit before closing.

4. Pride: Fighting the Market

Stubbornness is expensive. The market doesn’t care how much research you’ve done or how strongly you feel. Doubling down on a bad trade only compounds the error.

Avoid It:

• Write your exit plan before entering.

• Never average down a conviction trade simply to “prove you’re right.”

• Treat being wrong as routine-because it is.

5. Complacency: Trading Without an Edge

Sloth in trading isn’t about laziness, it’s about indifference to the numbers. Entering trades without checking implied volatility, expected move, or probability of profit is gambling, not trading.

Avoid It:

• Evaluate IV rank and probability before committing.

• Look for setups with a realistic statistical edge.

• Use the Greeks to understand how your position will behave.

6. Envy: Copying Other People’s Trades

Social media amplifies envy. For every screenshot of a 1,000% win, there are a dozen unspoken blowups. Chasing someone else’s lottery ticket is a quick way to torch your account.

Avoid It:

• Don’t mimic trades you don’t understand.

• Build and follow your own framework.

• Respect that flashy gains rarely come without hidden risks.

7. Overtrading: Mistaking Activity for Edge

With options, opportunities are endless. But more trades don’t mean more profits-they usually mean more slippage, more commissions, and more mistakes.

Avoid It:

• Focus on a handful of high-quality setups.

• Define entry rules and refuse to force trades.

• Remember that patience is a strategy.

The Difference Between Survivors and Casualties

Options trading isn’t about predicting the future. It’s about managing risk more effectively than the next trader.

• Greed magnifies losses.

• Impatience erodes probability.

• Fear scrambles decision-making.

• Pride resists reality.

• Complacency abandons the math.

• Envy distorts judgment.

• Overtrading buries the edge.

The antidote is discipline, position sizing, probability, and a willingness to sit out when no edge exists.

The traders who last aren’t those with perfect foresight. They’re the ones who avoid self-inflicted wounds.

Probabilities over predictions,

Andy Crowder

🎯 Ready to Elevate Your Options Trading?
Subscribe to The Option Premium—a free weekly newsletter delivering:
✅ Actionable strategies.
✅ Step-by-step trade breakdowns.
✅ Market insights for all conditions (bullish, bearish, or neutral).

📩 Get smarter, more confident trading insights delivered to your inbox every week.

📺 Follow Me on YouTube:
🎥 Explore in-depth tutorials, trade setups, and exclusive content to sharpen your skills.

📘 Join the conversation on Facebook.