This website uses cookies

Read our Privacy policy and Terms of use for more information.

The Desperation Trade: Why Your Worst Trade Comes When You're Behind and the Clock Is Running Out

I used to blame this trade on fatigue. The evidence points somewhere else: a loss, a deadline, and one last chance to get even.

At a racetrack, something odd happens in the last race of the day.

All afternoon, bettors spread their money in the usual way, heavy on the favorites and light on the long shots. Then the final race comes up and the long shots get crowded. Researchers who studied track betting found the shift was so strong that, in some of their data, a dull bet on the favorite to finish in the top three became profitable in the last race, even after the track took its cut.

Nothing about the horses changed. The bettors did. By the last race most of them were behind, and it was their final chance to go home even. A favorite couldn't get them there. A long shot could.

Markets have last races too. Friday's close. The end of the month. December 31.

As I write this, there are six weeks left in the year. The S&P 500 sits about 3 percent below its October 6 record after falling 4.4 percent in a single day on November 5. A lot of accounts that were green in October aren't anymore. That's the setup for what I call the desperation trade.

❝

The short answer: A desperation trade is a position taken to get back to even before a deadline, not because the setup meets your rules. Research on professional traders shows that those with losses in the morning took more risk in the afternoon. In options, the trade usually looks like a normal high-probability position at several times the normal size. It often works, which is why the habit survives until the one time it doesn't.

What I Got Wrong the First Time

An earlier version of this article blamed the desperation trade on a drained mind. Willpower, the theory went, is like a muscle: every decision uses some up, and by late afternoon the tank is empty.

It's a tidy story. It hasn't held up well.

Claim

What the evidence says

Willpower drains like a muscle

In 2016, 23 labs reran the experiment with 2,141 people. The effect was close to zero.

Judges rule more harshly as the day wears on

A famous study found approvals fell from about 65 percent to near zero before each break. Critics showed the order of cases wasn't random.

Traders who are behind take more risk late in the day

Found among professional futures traders. Details below.

People who trade the most earn the least

Found in 66,465 household accounts. Details below.

So I can't tell you that your judgment runs dry at 3:47 on a Friday. Nobody can. Rest still matters, and I don't trade tired. But tired isn't the best explanation for this trade.

Behind is.

Behind, With a Clock

Two economists, Joshua Coval and Tyler Shumway, studied 426 professional traders in the Treasury bond pit at the Chicago Board of Trade. These were people trading their own money, all day, for a living. The study, published in the Journal of Finance, asked whether their morning results changed their afternoon behavior.

They did. Traders who lost money in the morning were about 16 percent more likely to take above-average risk in the afternoon. They made more trades and bigger trades. And the prices they pushed tended to snap back within minutes, which means they were paying up to do it.

These weren't amateurs, and they weren't confused. They were behind, and the closing bell was their last race.

Psychologists call this the break-even effect. After a loss, a bet that offers a chance to get all the way back to even becomes unusually attractive, far more than the same bet would be on a fresh day. Two things have to be present: a hole, and a finish line. Take away either one and the pull fades.

That's what separates this from the revenge trade, which I've written about before. Revenge is anger at a loss. Desperation is arithmetic against a deadline.

What It Looks Like in an Options Account

For an options seller, the desperation trade rarely looks like a lottery ticket. It looks responsible.

Say I have a $50,000 account that's down $1,300 on the year, with six weeks to go. My normal trade is a put credit spread on a hypothetical stock, XYZ, at $100:

  • Sell the $90 put, buy the $85 put, about 45 days out

  • Credit: $0.66 a share, or $66 a contract

  • Most I can lose: $434 a contract

  • Modeled chance XYZ finishes above $90: about 81 percent

My rule is to keep the maximum loss near 2 percent of the account, which I cover in how much to risk on a trade. That's two contracts. I'd collect $132.

But $132 doesn't finish the year green. So the thought arrives: same trade, same strikes, same 81 percent. Just twenty contracts.

Risk profile at expiration comparing 2 contracts and 20 contracts of the same 90 85 put credit spread on a 100 dollar stock, with the 2 contract position gaining 132 dollars or losing at most 868 dollars and the 20 contract position gaining 1,320 dollars or losing at most 8,680 dollars Same strikes, same odds. The only thing that changed is the size, and the size is the whole trade. Modeled prices, not live quotes.

Twenty contracts collect $1,320. The year is saved. And the most I can lose is $8,680.

Bar chart showing the 2.6 percent of the account the trader is trying to recover beside the 17.4 percent of the account put at risk to recover it. The hole is 2.6 percent of the account. The trade to fill it risks 17.4 percent.

I'd be risking 17.4 percent of my account to win back 2.6 percent. Nothing about the trade's odds improved. I just moved the finish line closer and paid for it with risk.

Why the Habit Survives: It Usually Works

Here's the uncomfortable part. Four times in five, that trade wins.

To see what the habit costs over time, I ran a simulation: 20,000 hypothetical traders, 200 trades each, on a $50,000 account. Each trade wins $333 four times in five and loses $1,000 one time in five. Then I changed one rule. After any loss, the trader triples the next trade, so that a single win erases the loss.

Bar chart of the chance of a 20 percent drawdown over 200 simulated trades: 6 percent for a trader who keeps size constant, 45 percent for a trader who triples size after each loss, and 84 percent when those tripled trades also have a lower win rate One rule changed. The chance of a 20 percent drawdown went from about 1 in 18 to nearly 1 in 2.

Trader

Typical profit

Chance of a 20% drawdown

Chance of ending down

Keeps size constant

$13,300

6%

5%

Triples after a loss

$19,300

45%

7%

Triples after a loss, on worse trades

$2,700

84%

44%

Simulated, not actual results.

Look at the second row. The trader who chases usually ends up with more money. That's the trap. The habit gets rewarded most of the time, so it gets repeated, and the cost only shows up as a drawdown eight times more likely.

The third row is closer to real life. A trade taken to hit a number by a date isn't selected the way my other trades are. If those rushed trades win just 70 percent of the time and not 80, the edge is gone and nearly half the traders finish in the red. That 70 percent is my assumption, not a measurement, but I've never seen a forced trade that was better than a patient one.

The Cost of Needing to Do Something

There's a quieter version of this, with no loss at all. Nothing sets up for two weeks and I start to feel behind anyway, a feeling I described in the strain of standing still.

The largest study I know on this looked at 66,465 household brokerage accounts from 1991 to 1996. The households that traded the most earned 11.4 percent a year. The market earned 17.9 percent.

Bar chart of annual returns from 1991 to 1996 for 66,465 household accounts: 18.5 percent for the least active traders, 16.4 percent for the average household, 11.4 percent for the most active traders, and 17.9 percent for the market More trades, less money. The most active households trailed the market by 6.5 percentage points a year.

How I Catch It

I call the thing that runs low here emotional capital. It's a metaphor, not a measurement, but it's a useful one: it's my capacity to take the next loss without changing how I trade.

Card listing five tells of a desperation trade: a number to hit, a date to hit it by, bigger size, a skipped checklist step, and the phrase just this once. If the trade has a target and a deadline that came from my account and not from the market, it's a desperation trade.

Five tells. I have a dollar figure in mind. I have a date in mind. The size is bigger than usual. I skipped a step on my pre-trade checklist. I hear myself say "just this once."

The Monday Morning Test. I ask one question: if it were Monday morning and I were flat on the year, would I take this exact trade at this exact size? If the answer is no, the trade isn't about the market.

Rules I set while calm.

  • Size never goes up after a loss. If anything, a smaller account means a smaller position.

  • When I catch one of the tells, I stop trading for at least 24 hours.

  • I judge results over months of trades, not by this week or this year's calendar.

What We Learned: There Is No Last Race

Summary card titled there is no last race, showing three beliefs behind a desperation trade and the correction for each: the deadline is real, even is a destination, and this one is different. The racetrack closes. The market opens again on Monday.

Image F: Summary card titled there is no last race, showing three beliefs behind a desperation trade and the correction for each: the deadline is real, even is a destination, and this one is different The racetrack closes. The market opens again on Monday.

  1. "The deadline is real." It isn't. Friday, month end and December 31 are lines on a calendar. The market reopens, and my edge doesn't expire with the year.

  2. "Even is a destination." The market doesn't know what I paid or what I've lost. Getting back to even is a goal that exists only in my account.

  3. "This one is different." It's the same trade with more contracts. If it wouldn't pass on a Monday morning, it doesn't pass now.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is a desperation trade?

A desperation trade is a position taken to recover a loss or hit a profit target by a deadline, such as the end of a week, month or year, when the setup or size would not otherwise meet the trader's rules.

Why do traders take more risk after losses?

Research on the break-even effect shows that after a loss, bets offering a chance to get back to even become more attractive. A study of Chicago Board of Trade professionals found that traders with morning losses took more risk in the afternoon.

How do I stop revenge or desperation trading?

Set rules in advance: never increase position size after a loss, pause after consecutive losses, use a written checklist, and judge results over many trades and not by a calendar deadline.

The Bottom Line

The bettors in the last race weren't stupid. They were behind, the day was ending, and a small sensible bet couldn't fix it.

My advantage over them is simple. Their track closes. Mine doesn't. There's another trade on Monday, and another year after this one, and the only way to lose that advantage is to bet as if there weren't.

Probabilities over predictions,

Andy Crowder

🎯 Ready to Elevate Your Options Trading?
Subscribe to The Option Premium, a free weekly newsletter delivering:
✅ Actionable strategies.
✅ Step-by-step trade breakdowns.
✅ Market insights for all conditions (bullish, bearish, or neutral).

📩 Get smarter, more confident trading insights delivered to your inbox every week.

📺 Follow Me on YouTube:
🎥 Explore in-depth tutorials, trade setups, and exclusive content to sharpen your skills.

📘 Join the conversation on Facebook.

This article is for educational purposes only and reflects how I trade and manage my own portfolios. XYZ is hypothetical, and its prices are modeled, not live quotes. Simulation results are hypothetical and are not actual trading results. Nothing here is a recommendation to buy or sell any security. It is not investment advice.