This website uses cookies

Read our Privacy policy and Terms of use for more information.

Conviction Under Uncertainty: How to Trade When You Can't See

Your gut is a poor instrument in a market panic, and an even worse one in a calm. Here's what the data since 2000 say about fear, comfort, and the only kind of conviction worth having.

A pilot who flies into a cloud loses the horizon. Within seconds, the inner ear starts lying. The plane banks gently and the body reports level flight. The pilot corrects for a turn that isn't happening and tightens the one that is.

In a 1954 study still cited in flight training, pilots with no instrument experience were flown into simulated cloud. Every one of them lost control. The average time was 178 seconds.

The cure wasn't courage. It was a rule drilled into every instrument pilot since: when your body and the gauges disagree, trust the instruments.

Markets are cloud. On November 5, the S&P 500 fell 4.4 percent in a day and the VIX, the market's fear gauge, jumped to 28. Four trading days later it was under 18. Nobody saw either move coming, and anyone who says they did is describing a feeling.

I've traded options for more than two decades. I have never met anyone who knew the next move with any consistency. What I have met are people who keep placing sensible trades without knowing. That's conviction, and it has almost nothing to do with confidence.

❝

The short answer: Conviction in options trading isn't certainty about the next trade. It's trust in a tested process across hundreds of trades: know the odds before you enter, size every position small enough to survive being wrong, and decide your exit in advance. In S&P 500 data going back to 2000, how a trade felt at entry said little about how it ended. The calmest markets produced the worst single losses.

Your Gut Is a Bad Instrument, in Both Directions

Most traders believe two things. Calm markets are safe. Scary markets are dangerous. I tested both.

Using daily SPY and VIX data from 2000 through November 2026, I modeled the same simple trade on each of 6,725 days: sell a 45 day put about one expected move below the market and hold it to expiration. Then I sorted the results by how frightened the market was at entry.

VIX at entry

Premium per $100

Cushion below market

Average result

Worst result

Under 15 (calm)

$0.37

4.5%

$0.18 gain

$29.12 loss

15 to 20

$0.49

6.1%

$0.02 loss

$28.82 loss

20 to 30

$0.67

8.4%

$0.20 gain

$26.16 loss

30 to 40

$0.92

11.8%

$0.59 gain

$14.07 loss

40 and up (panic)

$1.33

17.8%

$1.09 gain

$10.47 loss

Per $100 of strike price. Modeled prices, not live quotes.

Bar chart of modeled put premium per 100 dollars of strike by VIX level at entry, rising from 37 cents when the VIX is under 15 to 1 dollar 33 cents when the VIX is 40 or higher, with the cushion below the market rising from 4.5 percent to 17.8 percent

Bar chart of modeled put premium per $100 of strike by VIX level, from $0.37 to $1.33

The first two columns are no surprise. When the market is frightened, the same trade collects more than three times the premium, with a strike four times farther away.

The last column is the surprise.

Two panel bar chart by VIX level at entry showing the average result per 100 dollars of strike, from an 18 cent gain in calm markets to a 1 dollar 9 cent gain in panics, beside the worst result, from a 29 dollar 12 cent loss in calm markets to a 10 dollar 47 cent loss in panics The calm trades paid the least and, when they failed, lost the most.

The worst single outcome since 2000 didn't come from selling into a panic. It came from a put sold on February 6, 2020, with the VIX under 15 and the market near a record. Six weeks later, SPY was down by a third.

Comfort isn't safety. It's the absence of a warning.

I need to be careful here, because the opposite lesson is just as wrong. This doesn't prove that fear is a buy signal. The 193 panic days in the data come from only about ten episodes, and two crises, the one that began in 2008 and the one in 2020, supply most of them. The win rate was roughly 89 to 96 percent in every row, calm or panicked. Your feelings at entry, good or bad, are a poor forecast. That's the finding.

Same Fear, Two Endings

Here are two Mondays that felt identical.

August 8, 2011. Standard & Poor's had just stripped the United States of its top credit rating after the debt ceiling fight. SPY fell 6.5 percent to $112.26. The VIX closed at 48.

September 29, 2008. The House voted down the bank rescue bill. SPY fell 7.8 percent to $111.38. The VIX closed at 46.72.

Run the same trade on both days and the model gives nearly the same ticket: a put struck near $93, roughly 17 percent below the market, for about $1.19 in 2011 and $1.16 in 2008.

Line chart of SPY over the 45 days after August 8, 2011 and after September 29, 2008, both starting near 112 dollars, with the 2011 path holding above its starting price and the 2008 path falling to about 84 dollars, well below the 93 dollar put strike marked on the chart Two panics, one trade. In 2011 it never came close. In 2008 it went through the strike and kept going.

In 2011, SPY never closed below its entry price for the next 45 days. The put expired worthless and the seller kept everything.

In 2008, SPY fell to $83.95 within a month, far below the strike. By expiration it had recovered to $91.17, leaving a loss of $0.78 a share. A trader who waited one week and sold the same kind of put on October 6 lost $8.96 a share, the worst panic trade in the data.

Nobody standing in either Monday could tell which one they were in. The trader who survived both didn't have better foresight. That trader had a smaller position.

Conviction Is About the Process, Not the Trade

Conviction doesn't mean "this trade will work." It means "this process works if I repeat it enough times, and I've sized it so I can."

That second half matters. Repetition only helps if the process has an edge. As I showed in my piece on the law of large numbers, a large sample delivers your average result, whatever that average is. Conviction in an untested process is just persistence.

It's also easy to confuse conviction with its expensive cousin.

Conviction

Stubbornness

Decided before the trade

Decided after the loss

About the process

About this one position

Has a size limit

Adds to the loser

Has a written exit

"It'll come back"

An earlier version of this article said that if a trade feels hard, the edge might be there. I'd take that back. Discomfort isn't an instrument either. A trade can feel awful because premiums are rich, or because your position is too big, or because you're wrong. Only the numbers can tell you which.

What It Looks Like in Practice

Say a hypothetical stock, XYZ, trades at $100 on a frightened day. Implied volatility is 32 percent. I want a trade I can hold through anything, so I use a put credit spread, which caps the loss.

  • Sell the $90 put, 45 days out, for $1.00

  • Buy the $85 put for $0.34

  • Credit: $0.66 a share, or $66 a contract

  • Most I can lose: $4.34 a share, or $434 a contract

  • Breakeven: $89.34, more than 10 percent below the stock

Risk profile of a 90 85 put credit spread on a 100 dollar stock at expiration, showing a 66 dollar gain per contract at any price above 90 dollars, breakeven at 89 dollars 34 cents, and a maximum loss of 434 dollars at 85 dollars or below Hypothetical XYZ at $100. The loss stops at $434 no matter how far the stock falls. Modeled prices, not live quotes.

On a calm day, with volatility at 16 percent, the same structure sits at $95 and $90, pays $0.47, and gives half the cushion.

Now the part that does the real work. In my own portfolios I keep the maximum loss on any position near 2 percent of the account, the rule I explain in how much to risk on a trade. On a $50,000 account, that's $1,000, so two spreads. If this turns out to be October 2008, I lose $868. That's annoying. It isn't fatal.

Losing streaks aren't bad luck. They're arithmetic. A strategy that wins 80 percent of the time has better than a 1 in 5 chance of four straight losses somewhere in 200 trades.

Bar chart of account drawdown after four maximum losses in a row at different position sizes: 7.8 percent down when risking 2 percent per trade, 18.5 percent at 5 percent, 34.4 percent at 10 percent, and 59 percent at 20 percent The same four losses. At 2 percent a trade, it's a bad month. At 20 percent, you need a 144 percent gain to get back to even.

Size is what turns a belief into something you can actually hold. You can't trust your process through a storm if one more loss ends your account.

What We Learned: The Instrument Panel

Pilots don't fly through cloud on nerve. They scan a few gauges, over and over. Here are mine.

Summary card titled the instrument panel showing four gauges for trading under uncertainty: odds, size, exit, and logbook Four gauges. None of them is a forecast.

  1. Odds. Before entry, I know the probability, the breakeven, and the most I can lose. If I can't state all three, I'm not in cloud. I'm lost.

  2. Size. About 2 percent of the account at risk per position. This is the gauge that keeps the others readable.

  3. Exit. Written down before the trade, when I'm calm. In the moment, I follow it.

  4. Logbook. I write down how the trade felt at entry and how it ended. Over time, the log shows how little those two things have to do with each other.

Frequently Asked Questions

What does conviction mean in options trading?

Conviction is trust in a tested, repeatable process over many trades, not certainty about any single trade. It rests on knowing your probabilities, limiting position size, and defining exits before you enter.

Is it better to sell options when the VIX is high?

Historically, premiums were richer and strikes farther away when the VIX was high, and modeled put sales earned more on average. But high VIX readings also came before some severe losses in 2008, so position size matters more than timing.

How do I trade when the market is uncertain?

The market is always uncertain. Use defined risk trades, keep the maximum loss on each position to a small share of your account, and judge yourself on whether you followed your process, not on one outcome.

The Bottom Line

The fog doesn't lift. On the calm days you just can't see it.

What you can do is stop asking your stomach for directions. Know the odds. Keep the size small. Write the exit down. Then place the next trade, not because you're sure, but because you've built something that doesn't need you to be.

Probabilities over predictions,

Andy Crowder

🎯 Ready to Elevate Your Options Trading?
Subscribe to The Option Premium, a free weekly newsletter delivering:
✅ Actionable strategies.
✅ Step-by-step trade breakdowns.
✅ Market insights for all conditions (bullish, bearish, or neutral).

📩 Get smarter, more confident trading insights delivered to your inbox every week.

📺 Follow Me on YouTube:
🎥 Explore in-depth tutorials, trade setups, and exclusive content to sharpen your skills.

📘 Join the conversation on Facebook.