Hedging a Poor Man’s Covered Call: Protective Puts, Spreads, and Tail Risk Overlays

Introduction: The Blind Spot in Capital Efficiency

The Poor Man’s Covered Call (PMCC) is celebrated for its capital efficiency, stock-like returns with a fraction of the outlay. Yet efficiency is often confused with invincibility. The leverage embedded in a PMCC magnifies both the upside and the downside, and traders who ignore hedging quickly learn that “cheap” exposure can become expensive when volatility surges.

In professional money management, no serious strategy is left unhedged. Whether it’s a pension fund layering tail risk hedges, or a volatility arbitrage desk running collars, protection is always part of the playbook. Retail traders running PMCCs should be no different.

This article explores three institutional-grade hedging techniques, protective puts, spreads, and tail risk overlays, and shows how they can be applied to strengthen a PMCC portfolio without eroding its edge.

The Core Risk of a PMCC

At its foundation, a PMCC involves:

1. Long LEAPS call (deep-in-the-money, 1-2 years out, typically delta 0.75-0.85).

2. Short call (near-term, out-of-the-money, delta -0.15 to -0.40, typically 30-60 days).

This synthetic covered call reduces capital outlay but introduces risks:

• LEAPS decay in a bear market: Deep pullbacks erode intrinsic value.

• Volatility crush: If implied volatility contracts, LEAPS values decline disproportionately.

• Gap risk: Large overnight moves can overwhelm collected premium.

A systematic hedging framework addresses these exposures while keeping the PMCC’s structural benefits intact.

Hedge #1: Protective Puts - Insurance for Capital

The simplest hedge is the protective put, a long put purchased against the LEAPS position.

• How it works: Buy an out-of-the-money put (often 10–15% below spot).

• Objective: Define the maximum loss on the LEAPS component.

• Cost trade-off: Premium outlay reduces net credit, but downside certainty can be worth the drag.

Example:

• Long AAPL Jan 2027 120 call (stock at $180).

• Short AAPL Oct 2025 200 call.

• Hedge: Buy AAPL Jan 2027 150 put.

This structure creates a synthetic collar, placing a floor under the LEAPS while still allowing covered-call income.

Academic context:
Empirical studies (e.g., Leland, 1985; Figlewski, 1989) demonstrate that protective puts consistently reduce portfolio variance, though at the cost of lower mean returns. In practice, traders who prioritize capital preservation often outperform peers who pursue raw return without risk adjustment.

Hedge #2: Spreads - Risk-Defined Adjustments

Protective puts are blunt instruments. Vertical spreads offer precision.

1. Bear put spread overlay

   • Buy a put closer to the money, sell a further OTM put.

   • Cheaper than outright protection, defines tail loss exposure.

2. Put ratio backspread

   • Sell one ATM put, buy two OTM puts.

   • Profits in a sharp selloff, small drag if flat.

3. Diagonal hedges

   • Match the LEAPS with a shorter-dated protective put.

   • Offers flexibility in adjusting hedges as volatility ebbs and flows.

Practical insight:
Spreads allow you to control the cost of insurance, a constant theme in both academic finance (Merton, 1973) and institutional practice. Like car insurance with a deductible, spreads let you choose how much pain you’re willing to self-insure before protection kicks in.

Hedge #3: Tail Risk Overlays - Preparing for the “Unthinkable”

Markets crash differently than they rally. Downside is clustered, fast, and nonlinear. This is where tail risk overlays become indispensable.

• VIX call options: Inexpensive in calm markets, explosive in panics.

• Deep OTM index puts: Buy S&P 500 or QQQ puts 20-30% below spot, months out.

• Put spread collars: Finance far OTM put purchases by selling near-OTM calls on the index.

Why it works:
Tail hedges are negatively correlated with equity drawdowns. When your LEAPS are bleeding, VIX calls or crash puts surge in value, offsetting losses.

Evidence:
Research by Broadie, Chernov, and Johannes (2009) and later by the Chicago Board Options Exchange (CBOE) shows that tail hedges, though costly on average, significantly improve Sharpe ratios and reduce drawdowns when integrated systematically.

Trader’s note: Think of these as fire extinguishers. Ninety percent of the time they collect dust. But in 2008, March 2020, or even August 2015, they pay for themselves a hundred times over.

📊 Trade Example Table

Sample Hedge on Apple (AAPL)

Takeaway: For ~$6,925 per contract, you replicate AAPL stock exposure (worth $18,000), generate covered-call income, and cap tail risk.

Implementation Framework

When hedging a PMCC, balance is everything:

1. Define objective: Are you hedging catastrophic loss, smoothing variance, or trading volatility?

2. Size correctly: No hedge should consume more than 10-15% of collected premium annually.

3. Monitor correlations: Single-stock PMCC hedges behave differently than index hedges, diversification matters.

4. Stay adaptive: Roll hedges as volatility shifts. A protective put bought at VIX 12 is cheap; at VIX 30, it’s expensive insurance.

The Behavioral Edge

The real benefit of hedging isn’t just mathematical, it’s psychological. Traders under-hedged during drawdowns often panic, close positions at the worst time, and miss the recovery. A modest hedge keeps you in the game, preserving both financial and mental capital.

“A hedge is less about making money and more about ensuring you don’t lose your nerve.”

Final Signals

Hedging a Poor Man’s Covered Call is not optional, it’s the professional step that separates disciplined traders from gamblers.

• Protective puts define risk.

• Spreads reduce insurance costs.

• Tail risk overlays prepare you for rare but devastating shocks.

The PMCC remains one of the most powerful tools in an income trader’s arsenal. But only when paired with a hedge does it transform from a leveraged bet into a repeatable, risk-managed strategy.

Probabilities over predictions,

Andy Crowder

Related Reading 📘

• Poor Man’s Covered Calls: The Definitive Guide

• How to Ladder Income Using Poor Man’s Covered Calls

• The Mathematics Behind Poor Man’s Covered Calls: Delta, Theta, and Probability

📩 Want to see how a 23+ year professional options trader approaches the market in real time?
Subscribe to The Option Premium, my free weekly newsletter where I share live trade examples, portfolio insights, and the probabilities behind every decision.

🎯 What You’ll Get Each Week:
✅ Actionable strategies for bullish, bearish, and neutral markets.
✅ Step-by-step breakdowns of real trades, including why I entered, how I sized positions, and how I’ll manage them.
✅ Market insights focused on probability and risk management, not hype or unrealistic promises.
✅ Education rooted in 23+ years of professional options trading experience.

🔑 A Realistic Approach to Options Trading:
Most traders chase shortcuts. I don’t.
My focus is on:

• Probability-based setups that can be repeated.

• Strategies that fit into a portfolio framework (not one-off gambles).

• Returns that compound steadily over time, not “get rich quick” pitches.

📩 Start trading smarter and more confidently, join thousands of readers who get The Option Premium every week.

📺 Want more education and community?
🎥 Subscribe on YouTube for in-depth tutorials and live trade breakdowns.
📘 Join the conversation on Facebook for exclusive insights, discussions, and real-time updates.